I wear a 10.5 shoe, I ordered a 10 for these boots but they were far too big. I just got the 9s in the mail, they're maybe a bit snug but a pretty good fit. The customer service at Hanks was very helpful, they didn't charge me any shipping costs on the return though I'm not sure if that's their policy or if it was a special. Overall these seem very well-made, but go a size lower when you order.

I love these boots.

They seem almost indestructible, solid one piece injection molded.
Light weight, totally waterproof, and not heavily lined which means they dont get hot. All hard to find in a boot.

I have these and the taller full boot version (different label), both are great for anywhere you might get wet, muddy, dirty, etc..
I wear them at the beach, river, dog park, camping, they are great to just slip on and go, work, casual, whatever.

Don't care what you step or walk in because they are they are easy to clean, just hose off.

Easy to slip on.

Only caution is they run SMALL....I wear a 9.5 wide in other shoes, I needed a 11.5 in these, and they fit great.

My mother-in-law bought me a pair of these for my birthday. I had a cruddy pair of discount store boots, and had just moved to her farm.

What I like about these boots:

They are very easy to put on with pull tabs at the front and back of the ankle opening.

They are very waterproof.

They clean off easily.

What I don't like:
They are too large, even though I bought my size. They slide on my feet unless I wear thick socks.

They are NOT slip resistant. This week alone, I've slipped and almost fell - once on wet linoleum, once on rain-slick steps and once on the wood floor of my chicken coop. They have great traction in dirt, but not at all on wet surfaces.

Maybe the ankle opening is snugger on men, but there is virtually no support since the opening is larger than my ankle/leg. Also, I find that working in the garden, I end up with dirt in my shoes and my socks since dirt gets up over the boot opening.

I would not recommend these to a friend, but due to the cost, I'm going to make due with them until at least next season.

I bought these boots as a Christmas present for my husband. He's a big guy and has always had a problems with any shoe/boot that is more than ankle-high. These are lightweight, and they fit like a dream. He's not going to be able to wade in deep water in these, but they are wonderful for traipsing around on our country property in this wet winter weather. He absolutely loves the boots; they are comfortable and keep his feet dry and warm.

I was a little unsure about buying the boots because they are a little expensive for what I was looking for, but when I got them, I realized they were worth it. They are amazingly comfortable, easy to move in, great for shoveling snow, wet yard work in the fall, anything really. They are easy to slip on, and fit comfortably. I would suggest buying a size down unless you plan to wear really thick socks like they recommend. I didn't realize this at the time and now I use two pairs of regular thickness socks, which is no bother really. All in all, great rain/mud/snow boots. Will buy from Muck Boots in the future.